top of page
White Room

Beyond Toys & Turkeys: Transforming Our Generosity


"Innovation in philanthropy means looking beyond immediate needs to the systemic barriers that keep inequality in place. It's about rewriting the narrative of giving, from temporary aid to lasting empowerment." - Angela Glover Blackwell, Founder in Residence, Policy Link



A Season of Transformation

As the holiday season approaches, our thoughts often turn to the spirit of giving. Many of us are moved by a deep-seated desire to give back. It's a time when we witness an outpouring of generosity through increased volunteer efforts and acts of charity, like distributing toys, turkeys, and other forms of charity. While these efforts are commendable, they are only temporary, seasonal solutions to more profound, systemic issues. When the holiday festive spirit ends and the winter chill sets in, a question lingers: "What happens next?" If a family needs food, clothing, and toys to survive the holiday season, underlying issues related to housing, health, nutrition, finances, transportation, and education may also need to be addressed.

How do we move from these generous charitable acts of giving that offer short-term feel-good relief and explore the concept of catalytic philanthropy that will amplify our giving and facilitate systems change to address the root cause of the issues?

Actionable Steps Towards Innovative Systems Change

Are we willing to journey and discover more innovative philanthropy solutions that enhance these gestures of generosity? Leveraging more imaginative philanthropy is essential for creating sustainable, systemic change. It addresses the duality of providing immediate relief while nurturing and empowering communities for long-term self-sufficiency and prosperity. It's a path that leads to our giving having a greater impact beyond the holiday season that helps to uplift, empower, and spark lasting change. This requires an innovative and transformative approach to address the underlying systems contributing to the need to distribute turkeys and have toy drives while embracing the fundamental commitment to serving the greater good of humanity with dignity and respect. Here are seven actionable steps that can be a part of this transformative journey:

  1. Build Relationships with Communities: Are we willing to listen and work with our communities differently? Imagine a world where every act of giving starts with listening, how we show up and support community conversations and vibrant gatherings where voices from all walks of life share their stories and dreams, know the communities best, and guide our actions. Together, we evaluate our impact through their eyes, ensuring that every step we take aligns with their aspirations.

  2. Reimagine Charity-Based Giving: How do we transform our philanthropic approach from traditional charity to one that respects and empowers the persons and families we seek to help? It requires collaborative discussions on innovative giving models between the community and non-profits, faith communities, government, and philanthropy that can help shift the narrative from a charity-focused model of giving to an empowerment approach, which involves embracing methods like direct cash assistance, which is a move away from prescriptive aid. This approach seeks to respect the dignity and agency of individuals and families, trusting them to know best what they need. Instead of predetermined gifts, they have the agency and autonomy to use the resources to address what matters most to them. Initiatives like Up Together and Mayors for a Guaranteed Income champion this approach of allowing families the flexibility to address their most pressing needs, whether it's for education, health, housing, transportation, or sustenance. This form of giving recognizes that families are the best judges of their needs. By providing direct cash assistance, we are not just offering help; we are showing respect and trust in the family's ability to make wise decisions for themselves, and this can be pivotal for a systemic change in how support is perceived and delivered.

  3. Empowering Through Skills and Resources: Picture a future where the potential is nurtured by investing in people in ways tailored to ignite individual talents, whether in crafts, technology, or entrepreneurship. Our resources and investment become beacons of learning and growth, equipped with tools for knowledge and connectivity by connecting aspiring minds with experienced guides and mentors who support turning dreams into tangible realities.

  4. Crafting Collaborations of Change: Envision a tapestry of cooperation where there is an intimate understanding of community assets and needs, leaning on a community-centered approach where the community and families can engage with non-profits, philanthropic, faith-based, government and businesses to intertwine their strengths, creating a robust network of support and innovation, by partnering together to craft solutions that resonate and endure beyond a holiday season.

  5. Innovating for Impact: Dream of a world where creativity meets compassion. Innovation is a viable, yet often underutilized, means of discovering solutions to these complex social issues and facilitating access to much-needed opportunities. Technology can be a catalyst for bridging gaps and opening new avenues for investment. Social entrepreneurship can flourish and tackle societal challenges with ingenuity. Unconventional alliances can form, bringing diverse perspectives and unconventional solutions to the forefront.

  6. Measuring the Waves of Change: How do we measure change? In this journey, our compass is the lasting impact we create. We develop metrics that reflect immediate relief and elevation of wellness, wealth, and well-being through a transparent process, shared openly, and build trust and accountability. We learn, adapt, and grow, fueled by both our successes and lessons learned.

  7. Creating a Symphony of Advocacy: Advocacy isn't just a step but an essential part of this process. It's an action needed and necessary to support and make a lasting impact with our generosity. It's the heartbeat of transformative change. It's about raising our voices to champion policies and initiatives that address root causes rather than just symptoms. When we leverage advocacy, we're not just asking for temporary fixes but building toward systemic change. This involves active participation in community-led advocacy, which empowers community members with the tools and platforms to speak out about their needs and solutions to lead advocacy efforts. Also, through active policy engagement, policy development and reform involve families and advocates collaborating with policymakers to inform and shape policies that directly affect the issues impacting their families and where they live. Finally, strategic partnerships with placed-based community and national organizations like The Commonwealth Institute, ChildSavers, and Policy Link, who are already deeply engaged in advocating for economic equality, children's mental health and development, and social-economic equity, help amplify collective voice, making advocacy efforts more powerful and far-reaching.

Reflective Questions to Reimagine Our Generosity


  1. Root Cause Reflection: How are we addressing the root causes of the issues we aim to solve, not merely soothing symptoms?

  2. Community Empowerment: How do our actions support, uplift, and empower the communities we serve?

  3. Innovation Pathways: What innovative avenues can we adopt for sustainable change?

Interactive Exercises to Amplify Our Generosity


  1. Community Immersion: Gain firsthand insight into the challenges and potential solutions by spending time in the communities being served- truly listening - to the heartbeat of the communities.

  2. Brainstorming Innovation: Encourage teams to gather to think outside the box and reimagine how to remove barriers by crafting creative solutions for systemic change that are as unique as the challenges they address.

  3. Impact Exploration: Together, celebrate the wins, identify areas that need improvement and further investment, and assess the long-term impact of current initiatives and expansion.

A Promise Beyond the Season

Once the holiday festivities end, our commitment to transformative philanthropy and system change should not. This holiday season, let's commit to enhancing our generosity by being catalysts for change, transcending beyond toys and turkeys to forge a future of systemic empowerment where we are willing to make a promise that extends beyond the season and pledge not just to give gifts but to enrich, empower and elevate for a brighter, more equitable tomorrow.

 

We would love to hear from you!

Share your experiences on this topic in the comments below


39 views0 comments
bottom of page